Past Masters of Mount Holyoke Lodge
| *Rev. George E. Fisher | 1870-71 |
| *Lewis B. Hooker | 1872-73 |
| *M.V.B. Jenkins | 1874 |
| *Charles Church | 1875 |
| *Lewis B. Hooker | 1876-77 |
| *James O. Walker | 1878-79 |
| *William N. Price | 1880 |
| *Phillip Hyde | 1881-83 |
| !*Horace W. Gaylord | 1884 |
| *Earl M. Scott | 1885-87 |
| *Schertrum E. Bliss | 1888 |
| *William H. Smith | 1889-90 |
| *Myron H. Judd | 1891-92 |
| *Fred M. Smith | 1893 |
| *Will W. Gaylord | 1894-95 |
| *Frederick B. Herrick | 1896 |
| *Albert D. Clark | 1897 |
| *Albert G. Hahn | 1898 |
| *Henry E. Gaylord | 1899 |
| *George M. Selfridge | 1900 |
| *Harrison E. Dunbar | 1901 |
| *Harry E. Brainerd | 1902-03 |
| *Charles J. Bartlett | 1904 |
| *Ray P. Scott | 1905 |
| %*David E. Hattiman | 1906 |
| *Hugh Sinclair | 1907-08 |
| *Ernest T. Brown | 1909-10 |
| !*Charles H.Smith | 1911 |
| *Frederick H. Webster | 1912 |
| %*Leon H. Dunklee | 1913 |
| *Albert Hagar | 1914 |
| !*David Glassford | 1915 |
| *William H. Downs | 1916 |
| *Marine Cooper | 1917-18 |
| *Ralph N. Batchelor | 1919 |
| *Alexander B. Sinclair | 1920 |
| *Irving Royston | 1921 |
| *Robert Hall | 1922 |
| *George F. Canney | 1923 |
| *James C. Weir, Jr. | 1924 |
| *Norman H. Richards | 1925 |
| *Dwight H. Eaton | 1926 |
| *William H. Brown | 1928 |
| *James J. Ingham | 1927 |
| *Albert Sorton, Jr. | 1929 |
| *Carl A. Carlson | 1930 |
| *Ralph H. Burnett | 1931-32 |
| #!*Ralph B. Wilson | 1933 |
| &*Ronald Astley | 1934 |
| *Robert A. Brainerd | 1935 |
| *Stanley A. Scott | 1936 |
| *Edwin A. Lewis | 1937 |
| *Samuel A. Watson | 1938 |
| *Harold Hanson | 1939 |
| *Clarence H. Smiledge | 1940 |
| *A. William Astley | 1941 |
| *Charles J. Buss, Jr. | 1942 |
| *J. Holden Camp | 1943 |
| #*Joseph G. Griffin | 1944 |
| *Ernest C. Smith | 1945 |
| *Joseph J. Lacey | 1946 |
| !*Huey H. McKay | 1947 |
| !*Edgar G. Thompson | 1948 |
| *Edward L. Norris | 1949 |
| * William A. Green | 1950 |
| *Charles Lempke, Jr. | 1951 |
| *Carlton O. Stiles | 1952 |
| *Robert T. Hardy | 1953 |
| *Robert W. Wilson | 1954 |
| #*Kenneth A. Snape | 1955 |
| #*W.K. Brooksbanke, Jr. | 1956 & 1982 |
| *Ernest E. Perron | 1957 |
| *Thomas S. Simpson | 1958 |
| *Clarence C. DeWolfe | 1959 |
| ^*Philip Hano | 1960 |
| ^*Alfred P. Charron | 1961 |
| * David W. Lewis | 1962 & 1993 |
| *William H. Colgan | 1963 |
| *Allan W. Stewart | 1964 |
| *Harrison B. Fecteau | 1965 |
| Frank Obremski, Jr. | 1966 |
| #Joseph R.P. Champagne | 1967 |
| #*Raymond I. Duff | 1968 |
| *Wilfred O. Hatch, Jr. | 1969 |
| !#*Francis R. Dressell | 1970 |
| *Albert D.J. Asprey | 1971 |
| ^#Richard B. Scott | 1972 |
| #*Waslter E. Schmitter | 1973 |
| #Kenneth S. Wilson | 1974 |
| +!#Ronald E. Jackson | 1975 |
| *Kenneth C. Haskins | 1976 |
| Leonard A. Neumann, Jr. | 1977 |
| #*Louis J. Laferrierre | 1978 |
| #Roger Martin | 1979 |
| #*Robert W. Tucker | 1980 |
| *James D. Hoisington | 1981 |
| Philip Hano, III | 1983 |
| *William I Mandell | 1984 |
| #Eugene G. Anderson | 1985 |
| Christopher D. Bascom | 1986 |
| %!John M. Gauger | 1987 |
| *William P. Daly | 1988 |
| ^#Raymond J. LeClair | 1989 |
| John E. Wehr, Jr. | 1990 & 1999 |
| ^#Henry A. Fusari | 1991-92 |
| ^ James A. Cassidy | 1994 & 1998 |
| %Donald L. Grise | 1995 |
| ~Donald T. Cherry | 1996 |
| ^!#Mark C. Mueller | 1997 |
| Clark Stevens Mandell | 2000 |
| Michael E. Wehr | 2002 |
| @#Donald C. Sargent | 2003 |
| % Brian T. Gibbons | 2004 |
| !Edward L. Alford | 2005 & 06 |
| ^ !Paul A. Cataldo | 2007-2008 & 2014-15 |
| Robert D. St. George | 2009 |
| %Ralph G.W. Lamy | 2010 |
| Karl F. Ferguson | 2011 & 2018 & 2019 |
| !Tyler W. Seavey | 2012 & 2013 & 2022 |
| %William C. Jubinville | 2016-2017 |
| Thomas D. Knightly | 2020 & 2021 |
| !Phillip W, Lambert | 2023 |
| ! John C. Scribner Jr. | 2024 & 2025 & 2026 |
&Senior Grand Warden 1949
!Past District Deputy Grand Master
@Past District Deputy Grand Master, Nantucket 31
#Past Master 16th/27th Lodge of Instruction
~President, Masonic Forum
^Joseph Warren Medal Recipient
*Deceased
%Demitted
